Maximum Metal Rating Legend
5 Excellent - Masterpiece. A classic.
4.5-4 Great - Almost perfect records but there's probably a lacking.
3.5 Good - Most of the record is good, but there may be some filler.
3 Average - Some good songs, some bad ones at about a half/half ratio.
2.5-2 Fair - Worth a listen, but best obtained by collectors.
1.5-1 Bad - Major problems with music, lyrics, production, etc.
0 Terrible - Waste of your life and time.

Note: Reviews are graded from 0-5, anything higher or not showing is from our old style. Scores, however, do not reveal the important features. The written review that accompanies the ratings is the best source of information regarding the music on our site. Reviewing is opinionated, not a qualitative science, so scores are personal to the reviewer and could reflect anything from being technically brilliant to gloriously cheesy fun.

Demos and independent releases get some slack since the bands are often spent broke supporting themselves and trying to improve. Major releases usually have big financial backing, so they may be judged by a heavier hand. All scores can be eventually adjusted up or down by comparison of subsequent releases by the same band. We attempt to keep biases out of reviews and be advocates of the consumer without the undo influence of any band, label, management, promoter, etc.

The best way to determine how much you may like certain music is to listen to it yourself.
3/7/2006 - Review by: Eric Compton
Saxon - Lionheart (Special Edition) - 2006 - SPV

Track Listing
1. Witchfinder General
2. Man And Machine
3. The Return
4. Lionheart
5. Beyond The Grave
6. Justice
7. To Live By The Sword
8. Jack Tars
9. English Man 'O War
10. Searching For Atlantis
11. Flying On The Edge
Many of you who read my previous "Lionheart" review will understand how high I hold this album within the Saxon discography. I honestly believe this is Saxon's finest work to date, a much needed return to past glory and a rousing success considering how far gone the band really was prior to this recording. This album finally found Biff and the boys on command and completely in charge, ruling their own domain in ways we could only imagine. Now the band have garnered critical praise as well as re-established themselves within their own fanbase. To ride the positive wave SPV presents a very special presentation of this stacked and solid recording. Now the label has unveiled a "Special Edition" of the album, and I must say they have really stepped up with a really great package for the Saxon fans.

This special edition of "Lionheart" comes packaged in a shiny black box. Within the box is of course the full CD, however along with that comes a whole host of metal goodies. Along with the fantastic recording comes a DVD extra filled with things like a "Lionheart" live video, "Beyond The Grave" video, a "making of" segment, as well as the song "Lionheart" in surround sound. If that isn't enough for the old salts SPV throws in a spiffy little Saxon keychain.

Bottom Line - A great way to take this fantastic album one step further! SPV is right on target by releasing this special edition of the record. A must have for fans of "Lionheart".

--EC 03.01.06

Album cover link:
Band link:
Label link:
9/15/2004 - Review by: Eric Compton
Saxon - Lionheart 2004 SPV Records - reviewed by: EC

Track Listing01. Witchfinder General
02. Man and Machine
03. The Return
04. Lionheart
05. Beyond the Grave
06. Justice
07. To Live by the Sword
08. Jack Tars
09. English Man 'O War
10. Searching for Atlantis
11. Flying on the Edge
Sometimes you can just look at an album's artwork and just know, just absolutely know in your heart, that the record will just smoke. Saxon's newest record, "Lionheart", courtesy of SPV Records, is a brilliant, non-stop metallic vision that refuses to fall into the same downward spiral as other "seasoned" veterans like Dio and Maiden. Clad in the glorious artwork of Paul Raymond Gregory, who also crafted the group's classic "Crusader"cover, "Lionheart" is a different type of Saxon record, one that sees the group emerging from a seven year drought that seemed to tarnish the English legends ("Unleash The Beast", "Metalhead", "Killing Ground"), while at the same time made many belive the band's direction and focus had been lost along with the nasty departure of two it's mainstay members, Steve Dawson and Graham Oliver.

With this new release, Biff and company decided to do a number of things differently. For the first time in fifteen years the band decided to record their new album in their homeland of England. How appropriate considering Saxon is one of the founding fathers of British heavy metal. Along with the change of scenery comes a different producer for the band, one Charlie Bauerfeind, known predominantly for his stellar work with Germans Rage and Blind Guardian, along with producing notable British acts like Halford and Motorhead. With the departure of drummer Fritz Randow, Saxon summons one of the best "behind the kit men" of the modern age, legendary stickman Joerg Michael. Famous for his performances in bands like Stratovarius, Grave Digger, and Rage, Joerg Michael brings a certain "Teutonic" feel to the band's sound, a prescious element that helps these blue-collar blokes break away from the restraints holding the band back year after year. Instead of relying on that same 'ole same 'ole sound, Saxon can now take advantage of the German landscape, mainly getting influences from both Bauerfeind and Michael, taking the lineup into the realms of power metal fury that they haven't visited in ages.

This type of album is very rare to find. Folks, there is no filler here whatsoever, just riff after riff of big-boy metal, not to be confused with symphonic, opera rock that Europe seems to be molding into radio friendly tunes fit for America. Indeed "Lionheart" is the perfect moniker for this slab of beef, the band proving they are armed to the teeth for this battle in the lion's den. With eleven iron-clad tracks that spell out C-L-A-S-S-I-C, Saxon have on their hands what I like to call "Album Gold". "Lionheart" will be my pick for album of the year, in fact I would have to say right now, on record, that this is the BEST metal album I've heard this millenium. Yeah, I said it. Give me one album out there this damn good! Biff explains this is the most powerful album the band has ever recorded, and I agree wholeheartedly. The album is just phenomenal, with roaring cuts like opener "Witchfinder General", the tight and speedy "Man And Machine", and power anthem "Lionheart". Biff is back to basics here, rough and ready at the helm, belting out metal thunder while being flanked on both sides by the powerful strings of Quinn and Scarratt.

Tracks like "Justice" and "Flying On The Edge" are total powerhouse numbers, delivering a fat mammoth hook while Michael plays "piece" keeper, staying within the lines and holding the songs together with his tight patterns and fast double bass. "Beyond The Grave" is a spooky little number, asking the age old question, what lies beyond? I love the band's pen work, with cuts like "Lionheart" and "English Man 'o' War" showcasing the English soldier's battle cries through history. The murky waters are unveiled with mid-pacer "Searching For Atlantis", while "To Live By The Sword" flies by night, keeping the armor shiny and gleaming even under the fastest conditions.

This is an instant classic and in my opinion the record that puts Saxon back on top. There just isn't anyone out there today that can make this record. "Lionheart" is pure Saxon through and through, recalling the "Power And The Glory" of years past. It is truly a blessing that these guys are back in shape, and back at the forefront of British heavy metal. This album is a masterpiece and one that will be treasured by this headbanger for years to come. Highly Recommended!!

--EC 09.15.04

Call To Arms
Eric Compton7/2/2011
Dogs Of War (Reissue)
Eric Compton3/31/2006
Into The Labyrinth
Eric Compton11/29/2008
Eric Compton3/7/2006
Eric Compton9/15/2004
Eric Compton4/26/2013
The Inner Sanctum
Eric Compton8/17/2007
Silver Lining
Eric Compton1/25/2018


<< back >>